We caught up with Jara Settles before she steps “Inside the Ring” at the 2026 South Dakota State Fair 4-H Show. Learn more about Jara below…
What is “nonnegotiable” for you when judging good livestock?
Assuming they’re all “good” and meet the basic obligations of being quality livestock, the appearance of care and effort is nonnegotiable for a champion. This is usually reflected in a high level of presentation.
What is your favorite part about working with the next generation of young people?
I like challenging the kids we help to think about the world more broadly. Many of us are from rural communities where everyone looks and thinks homogeneously. I see helping “our kids” to seek and understand a variety of perspectives is my role as a mentor.
What is your best piece of advice for someone looking to pursue a judging career?
Make friends who show or raise a variety of species so you can spend time learning transferrable skills and terminology. I’m also a big believer in junior college judging programs feeding into universities.
Biggest showmanship pet peeve?
Noses pointing at the rafters and the saggy toplines that result from them.
Do you prefer to judge on the profile or on the walk?
On the walk.
Favorite show you have judged?
Several years ago, my husband, Barrett Carlisle, and I had the chance to judge the ewes at the Indiana State Fair together. That was a special opportunity to share with my partner in sheep and in life and the livestock were outstanding.
If judges had a walkup song, what would yours be?
Welcome to the Jungle — by Guns N Roses
Skipper Carlisle would be so proud.
Go-to road trip snack?
Nerds Clusters.
What impression do you hope to leave on the crowd and exhibitors when you exit the ring after judging?
My focus is on the kids. I hope the crowd is able to hear and understand me, but my purpose is to make sure the exhibitors get a fair shake and an honest evaluation. For young kids, I hope they have a little fun and perhaps we can share a light moment. For the older exhibitors, I hope they can leave feeling respected and appreciated for their efforts.
